Should I Marry A Murderer? Cast, News, Videos and more

Woman with blond hair sitting on a brown sofa in a cozy living room, hands clasped, wearing a light gray sweater. Background includes a window with curtains, cushions, and a decorated mantelpiece. Natural light fills the room.
Woman with blond hair sitting on a brown sofa in a cozy living room, hands clasped, wearing a light gray sweater. Background includes a window with curtains, cushions, and a decorated mantelpiece. Natural light fills the room.
2026TV-MALimited Series
A fiancée turned key witness reveals how she stayed engaged to a man accused of murder while gathering evidence against him in this documentary series.
WatchTrailer
  • Where Is Caroline Muirhead Now? The True Story of Should I Marry a Murderer?
    When Caroline found out Sandy’s darkest secret, she stayed by his side.

Shop Should I Marry A Murderer?

Go to Netflix Shop

Episodes

Should I Marry A Murderer?

Limited Series

  • Episode 1
    In 2020, a Glasgow pathologist meets a Highland gamekeeper who seems perfect on paper. They're soon engaged — then a confession changes everything.
  • Episode 2
    As Caroline's actions give police a new lead in a cold case, she enters a terrifying double life with the McKellars — and hopes Sandy still trusts her.
  • Episode 3
    Torn between doing the right thing and protecting the man she can't walk away from, Caroline spirals as she desperately tries to avoid the witness stand.

Recaps

Popular Now

  • Here Are the 10 Most-Watched Movies of 2026 — So Far
    Have you watched them all yet?
  • Outer Banks Season 5: Watch the Revenge-Filled First 8 Minutes Early 
    The Pogues are out for blood in this thrilling sneak peek. 
  • The Dating App Killer Movie: Who Is Monica White?
    A woman meets a man online who she later discovers is a serial killer. 
  • The Last House Ending Explained: So What Are Those Creatures?
    Go under the surface to answer your deepest questions about the sci-fi thriller.
  • 23 Thrillers Too Suspenseful to Pause for Even a Second
    That’s how you know they’re great.
  • Outer Banks Season 5: The Pogues Return for One Last Ride on Aug. 20
    See some photos from the final season now.
  • Sunshine Girls Cast: Meet the Actors and Influencers Taking Valley High by Storm
    Head across the country — from the Upper East Side to Valley Hills, California
  • A New Documentary Series Explores the Ongoing Mystery of Mica Miller’s Death
    Death of the Pastor’s Wife features all-new footage and firsthand accounts.
  • New on Netflix in August 2026
    Stream The Whisper Man, The Last House, the final season of Outer Banks, and more.
  • Outer Banks Fans: Find Out Who Took Home the Gold at the Official Pogue Awards
    Who was the coolest Kook doing Kook things?
  • Meet the Man Who Lived Inside a Billboard for The Last House
    Nathan Shoop spent several days “trapped” 30 feet above Sunset Boulevard. 
  • My Life with the Walter Boys Season 3 Ending Explained and Discussed by the Cast
    A season that began with unknowns ended on an ominous cliffhanger.
  • 41 Comedies to Watch Whenever You Need a Laugh
    Smiles, chuckles, giggles, and full-on LOLs ahead.
  • Who Is Charles Manson? What to Know About the Latest Conversations with a Killer
    The series features recordings of the killer that’ve never been heard before.
  • The Bombing of Pan Am 103 Cast Guide: Meet the Investigators and Townspeople
    Connor Swindells, Patrick J. Adams, and Merritt Wever star in the series.
More from the stories you've watched
Sign in for behind-the-scenes stories and explainers
Sign In

Latest News

Popular Now